Advice Time!

Ok, so here is the sitch. I have this ottoman. This ugly ottoman. 

I want to reupholster it, but can't seem to find the perfect fabric. 

I also just got back from a nasty-mean workout with my trainer, so I may be a little light-headed and nutzo at the moment. Please help a girl out and send some advice my way! I know we're not a very talkative bunch, but let's hear it! Otherwise, I might end up with this:

Sorries to the actual owner of this ottoman.

So this is sort of what my heinous ottoman looks like:

Mine is a little different, but just as bad. Trust me.

And here are some of your fabric choices, all are Osborne and Little.

Oh, and both of these zebra print numbers were approved by Mr. Wonderful. I know, it shocked me too.

I'm all ova the place, right? I need some serious guidance.

I'm still lookin' around, but any advice or ideas would be amazeballs!

xoxo Meg